home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0872>
- <title>
- Jul. 04, 1994: Russia:City on Edge
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Jul. 04, 1994 When Violence Hits Home
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- RUSSIA, Page 50
- City on Edge
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> Mired in squalor, awash in glitz, Moscow struggles to find a
- sense of itself
- </p>
- <p>By Kevin Fedarko--Reported by Sally B. Donnelly, John Kohan, Ann M. Simmons and
- Yuri Zarakhovich/Moscow
- </p>
- <p> Like any reasonable businessman in Moscow, Boris Berezovsky
- took the possibility of an assualt on his life for granted.
- The chairman of Logovaz, the country's leading dealer in Zhiguli
- cars (a Russian-made Fiat), he never traveled without a bodyguard
- to ward off attacks by racketeers, competitors or any of the
- city's other assorted thugs. Yet such precautions couldn't prevent
- a remote-control car bomb from exploding as he walked out of
- his downtown office early this month. Berezovsky escaped with
- only burned hands. But his bodyguard suffered severe chest injuries
- that required six hours of surgery, six passersby were wounded
- and the driver of the car was decapitated by the blast.
- </p>
- <p> Such crimes have become depressingly familiar in Moscow. A day
- after the attempt on Berezovsky's life, an elderly man lost
- his leg to another car bomb. Two days after that, Alexei Yeliseyev,
- the second in command at Vnukovo Airlines, was beaten to death
- in front of his house. That same day two people were shot to
- death by gangsters during a car chase on the Rublev Highway.
- What surprised onlookers was not the sight of a high-speed gun
- battle along the heavily guarded road. It was the fact that
- a modest, Russian-made Zhiguli was able to overtake a more powerful
- Jeep Grand Cherokee.
- </p>
- <p> Events like these prompted Russian President Boris Yeltsin two
- weeks ago to announce a crackdown on what he described as the
- "criminal filth" plaguing Russia, and especially Moscow. His
- decree, giving the police broad new powers to conduct searches
- and detain suspects, drew a sharp outcry from civil libertarians
- and last week was overwhelmingly condemned by the Russian parliament.
- Yet it was a symbol of the desperation to which Moscow, the
- once proud seat of the Russian and Soviet empires, has been
- reduced.
- </p>
- <p> Today all the hopes, anxieties and contradictions of Russia's
- fumbling transition from communist monolith to Western-style
- free market are reflected in this city of 9 million. The crumbling
- of communism has rendered it a city adrift--a metropolis that
- has lost its sense of historic mission and is struggling to
- find a new identity worthy of its former grandeur. Moscow finds
- itself seized by a debilitating sort of urban schizophrenia.
- On one hand, a small but highly visible minority of residents
- are enjoying the rich possibilities of upheaval. "Life has never
- been more exciting in this city!" gushes a street entrepreneur.
- Others, however, are gripped by a feeling of profound disorientation,
- even despair. "There is no future here," says Vasili Alexeyev,
- who shares a single-room apartment with his wife and two sons.
- "Before, life in Moscow was bad; now it is even worse. We live
- without hope for tomorrow."
- </p>
- <p> Moscow has not always been this way. In 1916, a year before
- communism's whirlwind transformed Russia into the Soviet Union,
- the poet Marina Tsvetayeva described her native city as a vast
- hostelry of "forty times forty" churches, where small pigeons
- rose above the golden domes and the floors below were polished
- by kisses of the faithful. Under the Soviet regime, with its
- Stalinist housing bunkers and oppressive military bearing, the
- city became a grimmer place, but one that was anchored, orderly,
- predictable, even if, to many outsiders, drab and downcast.
- By 1976, the British journalist Geoffrey Bocca could describe
- the scene as a "crushing concatenation of faceless, shabby,
- shoving, rude and, above all, indifferent, uninterested people."
- </p>
- <p> Today, however, both these visual keynotes have been replaced
- by the chaos of capitalism's dikaya zhizn, or "wild life": weather-beaten
- babushkas who beg from filthy sidewalks, marauding bands of
- gypsy children, Lycra-skirted strumpets cavorting with Western
- businessmen, bankers tooling around town in armor-plated Mercedes,
- mafia moguls in sharkskin suits who dine on Maine lobster with
- a $238-a-bottle champagne in five-star hotels. A sense of bewilderment
- plagues Moscow's residents as they attempt to sort out the conflicting
- claims of their half-remembered, precommunist culture from the
- hedonistic and corrupting pull of the West. It is the sort of
- spiritual vertigo that accompanies economic and cultural free
- fall, and it has left many ordinary Muscovites with an uneasy
- feeling of limbo.
- </p>
- <p> And of fear. Criminal gangs have transformed a city that during
- the days of the Soviet police state was one of the safest in
- the world into a virtual criminopolis. Last year in Moscow police
- reported more than 3,000 murders--an increase of 1,740% since
- 1987. Those seven years also introduced a rash of previously
- unheard-of crimes, such as contract assassinations (about 100
- last year) and murders by bombing (which the police now call
- "good-morning murders" because the explosions usually go off
- around dawn). A presidential study has concluded that virtually
- every retail trade booth, store, cafe and restaurant in the
- Russian capital pays protection money of up to 20% of gross
- receipts to organized crime. Resisters are beaten or killed.
- "In my 17 years on patrol," says police Lieut. Gennadi Groshikov,
- "I have never seen so much crime in Moscow; nor have I seen
- anything as vicious."
- </p>
- <p> The authorities are trying to strike back. Last Tuesday, just
- after midnight, 20,000 soldiers and police in camouflage gear
- swept through several dozen Moscow hotels, businesses and banks,
- hoping to cripple the criminal gangs. In the meantime, citizens
- are afraid to go out at night; stores have difficulty keeping
- pistols, Mace and bulletproof jackets in stock; dinner conversations
- stop abruptly whenever a tail pipe backfires in the streets.
- "The crime problem today knows no limits," says Pavel Gusev,
- editor in chief of Moskovsky Komsomolets, who travels with a
- bodyguard. "In the U.S. your Mafia has already divided up spheres
- of business, so the bosses no longer kill each other off. Here
- we have a wild market where state holdings are being turned
- over into private hands."
- </p>
- <p> But Moscow's makeover is not just due to the crime explosion.
- A stroll through the center of the city reveals the transformation
- nearly everywhere. The city's seemingly ubiquitous statues of
- communist-era heroes, such as "Iron" Felix Dzerzhinsky, founder
- of the KGB, and Mikhail Kalinin, an early Bolshevik who once
- authorized the death penalty for children as young as 12, have
- been disdainfully torn down. Gone too are the metronomic boot
- clicks of the goose-stepping guards outside Lenin's tomb, who
- once immutably marked off the minutes and hours of the Soviet
- state. Remarked a Russian father as his family paid a visit
- to the mausoleum: "They used to stand for hours in line here."
- Now virtually no one comes.
- </p>
- <p> Tourists and shoppers flock instead to the McDonald's in Pushkin
- Square or to Tverskaya Ulitsa, Moscow's Fifth Avenue. There,
- dazzling neon signs invite motorists and pedestrians to savor
- the sensations of a swinging metropolis awash in restaurants,
- nightclubs and luxury boutiques. This is the new Russian capital,
- Moscow as Vegas of the North.
- </p>
- <p> The city's noviye bogati, or nouveaux riches, are a small but
- growing elite numbering some 300,000 (a class of notables whom
- 13% of the country, according to a survey conducted by Moscow
- News, would like to see thrown in prison). These are the post-Soviet
- sybarites who patronize Moscow's Volvo and Mercedes dealerships,
- pamper themselves with Estee Lauder "exclusive skin-care consultations"
- and blithely plunk down the equivalent of an average worker's
- monthly pay for French champagne and Danish liqueur candies
- at the gilded-mirror displays in Yeliseyevsky Gatronom, the
- grande dame of Moscow supermarkets.
- </p>
- <p> "These people feel good about themselves," says Alexander Fyodorov,
- a suntanned nuncio of the nouveaux riches who divides his time
- between homes in Moscow and Miami and business trips to Europe.
- "They earn good money, and they deserve to spend it however
- they want."
- </p>
- <p> Fyodorov, a former engineer, is the CEO of a company that sells
- everything from Twix candy bars to $80,000 Jaguars. His well-guarded
- headquarters, a suite of offices stylishly caparisoned in halogen
- lamps, marble tiles and tastefully understated artwork, occupies
- several floors of a converted kindergarten on Marshal Zhukov
- Street. Scurrying around the cubicles is a multilingual staff
- that manages Fyodorov's advertising firm, his home-security
- company, his men's clothing shop and his private day-care company
- (which supervises the offspring of wealthy jet-setters for $300
- a day). Fyodorov's other enterprises include Wild Orchid, a
- popular women's lingerie shop, and Collection, a luxury-car
- dealership.
- </p>
- <p> Unlike the old Soviet elite, who led quiet, if profoundly hypocritical,
- lives of sequestered privilege while paying lip service to Marxist
- notions of egalitarianism, the noviye bogati seem determined
- to part with their newfound wealth in the most ostentatious
- manner possible. "Russians who come to me want to spend their
- money and want it to show," says Mats Lofgren, a Swedish furniture
- dealer. "They won't waste their time on functional furniture.
- I show them the gold-plated faucets and ornate lamps, and they
- take it. I had a Russian come in recently who announced, `My
- friend just spent $50,000 doing his apartment, and I want the
- same. Only make it $60,000.'"
- </p>
- <p> For a stark contrast to this conspicuous opulence, one need
- only walk to the nearest metro station. Filled with lavish mosaics,
- frosted chandeliers and archways of stained glass, the metro
- offered a magnificent expression of Soviet splendor that belied
- the brutality of the era that produced it. Yet for millions
- of Muscovites who ride the trains each day, the metro no longer
- provides a voyage through a subterranean communist cathedral,
- whose effect is both sumptuous and muscular. Today it is overrun
- with beggars, reeling drunks and small-time entrepreneurs dragging
- trollies laden with crates and boxes.
- </p>
- <p> The scene is similar in the city's bustling train stations.
- In the crowded waiting room at Kursky station, one of the city's
- seediest, a teenage gypsy girl stood screaming while blood spurted
- from gashes on her arms. "I want to die," she wailed. "My life
- is nothing. I am pregnant, but no one believes me. They think
- I am lying." She raised a blood-splattered cardigan that reeked
- of urine to reveal her puffy belly. A middle-aged woman stopped
- to stare, as the howling resumed, "I can't bear this. I hate
- this life!" Several militiamen who work at the station turned
- to find out what the commotion was about. When they spotted
- the girl, they nodded their heads and continued their rounds.
- "What kind of people have we become?" asked another woman. Such
- scenes fill Muscovites with a sense of dazed anguish, partly
- because in the past any castoffs of the socialist state foolish
- enough to make a public appearance were either deported from
- the city or thrown into psychiatric prisons.
- </p>
- <p> Today at least 40,000 street tramps sleep in Moscow's metro
- tunnels and solicit change outside its new temples of affluence.
- That is still less than half the estimated homeless population
- of a city of comparable size, such as New York City. But places
- like Kursky station have become overrun by these panhandlers.
- Some are tubercular. Others are covered with skin ulcers and
- body sores. The existence of most is sufficient to provoke the
- spleen of passersby. "Disorder, dirt and a total lack of care
- for others," says Vera Alexeyev, a housewife who has lived in
- the city for more than 10 years, "is what strikes me most about
- Moscow today."
- </p>
- <p> Barely a step above the denizens of the streets are those who
- haunt Moscow's hard-luck flea markets. At these outdoor bazaars,
- the bottom of the city's economic food chain--mainly pensioners
- who brew "tea" with shredded carrots and can't remember the
- last time they bought a new scrap of clothing--peddle their
- household goods to pay for tomorrow's potatoes. A short stroll
- from Moscow's Kiev train station, the sidewalks teem with faucets,
- shower fittings, cartons of milk, boxes of laundry powder, lamps,
- washbasins, doorknobs, frying pans, toothpaste, glue, string
- and old pairs of shoes.
- </p>
- <p> Back in the Soviet era, when the criminal code barred trading,
- there were no peddlers. Now much of the country's economic engine
- is driven not by the haut monde boutiques on Tverskaya but by
- the corrugated larki, or street stalls, which have sprung up
- across Moscow (and which the city government moved in to control
- earlier this year). These sidewalk clearinghouses offer a bizarre
- inventory of items, from Pierre Cardin cigarettes to banana-flavored
- liqueurs, exotic massage oils, cut-rate lingerie, canned ears
- of baby corn and pirated videos of Western B-movies.
- </p>
- <p> Business is brisk, owing in no small part to the irrepressible
- spirit of Moscow's "hoboes"--the term favored by the city's
- free-market hucksters--who engage in a frenzy of buying and
- selling whatever goods they can lay their hands on. It is difficult
- to know whether these are the entrepreneurs who will eventually
- help rebuild the nation's economy or the scam artists who will
- pull it down. Perhaps they are a little of both. In any case,
- their impact has been undeniable: last year, by one estimate,
- hoboes moved 3 billion rubles' worth of goods and accounted
- for more than 10% of all officially registered trade.
- </p>
- <p> One such trader is Leonid, a lanky, unshaven roughneck who formerly
- belonged to an elite unit of the Soviet army. After leaving
- the military in the late 1980s, Leonid spent several years repairing
- apartments and fixing toilets, until he started brokering Russian-made
- wine in front of the Kiev railway station. When he was pushed
- out by a group of gypsies who controlled the wine trade, Leonid
- turned to imported cigarettes. Since then, he has branched out;
- one week he may move a consignment of flashlight batteries,
- the next a shipment of government-issue boots, obtained from
- a corrupt policeman. His ability to broker everything from investment
- bonds to manicure scissors can earn him 70,000 rubles a day.
- </p>
- <p> Despite the odor of seediness that clings to the hoboes, many
- are highly educated. Leonid is studying at a Moscow college.
- One of his colleagues, a linguist, spends his free time writing
- a semantic analysis of Communist Party documents. Another is
- a chemist who puts his skills to work by distilling juniper-berry
- moonshine for his friends. All are energized by the frenzied
- pace of street-corner capitalism, even as they fear the joyride
- may not last forever. Leonid, who once saw "unlimited possibilities
- for business," now is concerned that the government or the mafia
- may soon strangle the uncontrolled free market.
- </p>
- <p> But while inspiring to some, this sort of breakneck change seems
- only to increase the suspicion among many Muscovites that the
- qualities that once made their home special may be disappearing.
- Throughout its tumultuous past, this city always retained the
- atmosphere of a large smoke-filled kitchen, where people gather
- late at night to share and confide in an atmosphere of unselfish
- friendship. Muscovites rely on this "kitchen unity" as a kind
- of spiritual lodestar that guides them in more difficult times.
- </p>
- <p> Now, however, the city is being knocked off its bearings, forcing
- citizens to fend for themselves. "One of the most frightening
- things about life in Moscow," says Galina Volchek, director
- of the Sovremennik Theater, "is this sense of inner, psychological
- defenselessness; the feeling that you are totally alone in facing
- whatever may happen." Russians have a word for this feeling
- of vulnerability in the midst of wrenching change: bespredel.
- Its literal meaning perhaps best sums up the new Moscow: no
- limits.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-